Well, to make a long story short, after tweezers and witch hazel, I still could not get the darn thing out, and guess what, there were 2 down in there. She has the silliest belly button you've ever seen, it's an outtie in an innie, you can pull it out if you want. I had to get Daddy, who very calmly and sweetly took care of the ticks, talked her through it and got them out.
I've never seen her hug anyone as fast as she immediately hugged her daddy and thanked him. It was cute.
She said they like her and they think she's their home and that next time she is covering herself in bug spray. LOL
Thank the Heavens for Daddies! :)